| PAT kicks made |
| 1. 74 - Taylor Anderson (74-74) - 2012 |
| 2. 55 - Cody Watson (55-58) - 2023 |
| 55 - Sam Aviles (55-56) - 2019 |
| 55 - Brad Beckwith (55-58) - 2009 |
| 3. 54 - Dustin Strickler (54-55) - 2007 |
| 4. 52 - John Schmiemeier (52-54) - 2013 |
| 5. 40 - Brad Beckwith (40-43) - 2010 |
| 6. 38 - Robbie Walling (38-46) - 2005 |
| 38 - Kevin Toms (38-41) - 2000 |
| 38 - Greg Zuerlein (38-40) - 2011 |
| 38 - Kevin Toms (38-45) - 1999 |
|
| PAT kicks attempted |
| 1. 74 - Taylor Anderson (74-74) - 2012 |
| 2. 58 - Brad Beckwith (55-58) - 2009 |
| 58 - Cody Watson (55-58) - 2023 |
| 3. 56 - Sam Aviles (55-56) - 2019 |
| 4. 55 - Dustin Strickler (54-55) - 2007 |
| 5. 54 - John Schmiemeier (52-54) - 2013 |
| 6. 46 - Robbie Walling (38-46) - 2005 |
| 7. 45 - Kevin Toms (38-45) - 1999 |
| 8. 43 - Brad Beckwith (40-43) - 2010 |
| 9. 41 - Kevin Toms (38-41) - 2000 |
| 10. 40 - Greg Zuerlein (38-40) - 2011 |
|
| PAT kick pct (min. 10 attempts) |
| 1. 100.0 - Tyler Basch (10-10) - 2016 |
| 100.0 - Sam Aviles (10-10) - 2018 |
| 100.0 - John Schmiemeier (25-25) - 2014 |
| 100.0 - Taylor Anderson (74-74) - 2012 |
| 5. 98.2 - Sam Aviles (55-56) - 2019 |
| 6. 98.2 - Dustin Strickler (54-55) - 2007 |
| 7. 96.3 - John Schmiemeier (52-54) - 2013 |
| 8. 95.0 - Greg Zuerlein (38-40) - 2011 |
| 9. 94.8 - Cody Watson (55-58) - 2023 |
| 94.8 - Brad Beckwith (55-58) - 2009 |
| 10. 94.1 - Tyler Basch (32-34) - 2017 |
|
| Field goals made |
| 1. 23 - Greg Zuerlein (23-24) - 2011 |
| 2. 18 - John Schmiemeier (18-25) - 2014 |
| 3. 17 - Tyler Basch (17-20) - 2017 |
| 17 - Dustin Strickler (17-23) - 2006 |
| 4. 16 - Cody Watson (16-21) - 2024 |
| 5. 15 - Dustin Strickler (15-19) - 2008 |
| 15 - Brad Beckwith (15-22) - 2010 |
| 6. 14 - Brad Beckwith (14-22) - 2009 |
| 14 - Tanner Pettet (14-26) - 2015 |
| 14 - Cody Watson (14-20) - 2023 |
| 7. 13 - Tyler Basch (13-17) - 2018 |
| 8. 12 - Taylor Anderson (12-19) - 2012 |
|
| Field goals attempted |
| 1. 26 - Tanner Pettet (14-26) - 2015 |
| 2. 25 - John Schmiemeier (18-25) - 2014 |
| 3. 24 - Greg Zuerlein (23-24) - 2011 |
| 4. 23 - Dustin Strickler (17-23) - 2006 |
| 5. 22 - Brad Beckwith (15-22) - 2010 |
| 22 - Brad Beckwith (14-22) - 2009 |
| 6. 21 - Cody Watson (16-21) - 2024 |
| 7. 20 - Cody Watson (14-20) - 2023 |
| 20 - Tyler Basch (17-20) - 2017 |
| 8. 19 - Dustin Strickler (15-19) - 2008 |
| 19 - Taylor Anderson (12-19) - 2012 |
| 9. 18 - Robbie Walling (8-18) - 2005 |
|
| Field goal pct (min. 5 attempts) |
| 1. 100.0 - Taylor Anderson (5-5) - 2011 |
| 2. 95.8 - Greg Zuerlein (23-24) - 2011 |
| 3. 88.9 - Tristan Blagg (8-9) - 2003 |
| 4. 87.5 - Thomas Kopcho (7-8) - 2021 |
| 5. 85.0 - Tyler Basch (17-20) - 2017 |
| 6. 78.9 - Dustin Strickler (15-19) - 2008 |
| 7. 76.5 - Tyler Basch (13-17) - 2018 |
| 8. 76.2 - Cody Watson (16-21) - 2024 |
| 9. 73.9 - Dustin Strickler (17-23) - 2006 |
| 10. 72.7 - Dustin Strickler (8-11) - 2007 |
|
| Punt yards |
| 1. 2533 - Scott Groner (60-2533) - 2014 |
| 2. 2505 - Luke Theis (64-2505) - 2017 |
| 3. 2381 - Mike Darnell (58-2381) - 1998 |
| 4. 2380 - Tristan Blagg (59-2380) - 2003 |
| 5. 2363 - Matthew Vincent (60-2363) - 2015 |
| 6. 2353 - A. Fenstermaker (61-2353) - 2002 |
| 7. 2345 - Jamie Hanson (56-2345) - 2007 |
| 8. 2196 - Luke Theis (54-2196) - 2018 |
| 9. 2193 - Scott Groner (50-2193) - 2011 |
| 10. 2132 - Scott Groner (50-2132) - 2013 |
|
| Punt attempts |
| 1. 64 - Luke Theis (64-2505) - 2017 |
| 2. 61 - A. Fenstermaker (61-2353) - 2002 |
| 3. 60 - Scott Groner (60-2533) - 2014 |
| 60 - Matthew Vincent (60-2363) - 2015 |
| 5. 59 - Tristan Blagg (59-2380) - 2003 |
| 6. 58 - Mike Darnell (58-2381) - 1998 |
| 7. 57 - Kasey Waterman (57-2045) - 2001 |
| 8. 56 - Jamie Hanson (56-2345) - 2007 |
| 56 - Kasey Waterman (56-2001) - 2000 |
| 10. 54 - Luke Theis (54-2196) - 2018 |
|
| Average yards/punt (min. 5 attempts) |
| 1. 43.86 - Scott Groner (50-2193) - 2011 |
| 2. 43.58 - Jamie Hanson (38-1656) - 2008 |
| 3. 42.64 - Scott Groner (50-2132) - 2013 |
| 4. 42.58 - Evan Williams (38-1618) - 2023 |
| 5. 42.22 - Scott Groner (60-2533) - 2014 |
| 6. 41.88 - Jamie Hanson (56-2345) - 2007 |
| 7. 41.57 - Jay White (44-1829) - 2005 |
| 8. 41.25 - Scott Groner (40-1650) - 2012 |
| 9. 41.05 - Mike Darnell (58-2381) - 1998 |
| 10. 40.67 - Luke Theis (54-2196) - 2018 |
|
| Punt return yards |
| 1. 444 - Trey Vaval (21-444) - 2019 |
| 2. 329 - Br. Clark (23-329) - 2015 |
| 3. 322 - Jerris Evans (22-322) - 2001 |
| 4. 303 - Jarrett Brooks (21-303) - 2005 |
| 5. 298 - Jon Schoonover (17-298) - 2004 |
| 6. 270 - Brandon Burnside (24-270) - 1998 |
| 7. 266 - Pierre Thomas (25-266) - 2003 |
| 8. 240 - Brandin Dandridge (19-240) - 2018 |
| 240 - Brandon Burnside (12-240) - 1999 |
| 10. 238 - Jarrett Brooks (23-238) - 2006 |
|
| Punt returns |
| 1. 25 - Pierre Thomas (25-266) - 2003 |
| 2. 24 - Brandon Burnside (24-270) - 1998 |
| 3. 23 - Jarrett Brooks (23-238) - 2006 |
| 23 - Br. Clark (23-329) - 2015 |
| 5. 22 - Jerris Evans (22-322) - 2001 |
| 6. 21 - Trey Vaval (21-444) - 2019 |
| 21 - Jerris Evans (21-122) - 2000 |
| 21 - Jarrett Brooks (21-303) - 2005 |
| 9. 19 - Brandin Dandridge (19-240) - 2018 |
| 10. 17 - Jon Schoonover (17-298) - 2004 |
| 17 - Pierre Thomas (17-163) - 2002 |
|
| Punt return TDs |
| 1. 1 - Pierre Thomas - 2003 |
| 1 - Brandon Burnside - 1998 |
| 1 - Jarrett Brooks - 2006 |
| 1 - Br. Clark - 2015 |
| 1 - Jerris Evans - 2001 |
| 1 - Jeremy Weston - 2009 |
| 1 - Zach Sharp - 2006 |
| 1 - Jarrett Brooks - 2005 |
| 1 - Brandin Dandridge - 2018 |
| 1 - Offing Anita - 2001 |
| 1 - Erick Fields - 2003 |
| 1 - Tarrell Downing - 2011 |
| 1 - Devon Johnson - 2004 |
| 1 - Cedric Houston - 2007 |
| 1 - Darrian Bass - 2013 |
| 1 - Cedric Houston - 2009 |
| 1 - Jacob Schoonover - 2007 |
| 1 - James Huskey - 2018 |
| 1 - Cedric Houston - 2008 |
| 1 - Jerris Evans - 1999 |
| 1 - Derek Libby - 2013 |
|
| Average yards/punt return (min. 5 attempts) |
| 1. 21.14 - Trey Vaval (21-444) - 2019 |
| 2. 20.00 - Brandon Burnside (12-240) - 1999 |
| 3. 18.30 - Carlos Thompson (10-183) - 2018 |
| 4. 17.53 - Jon Schoonover (17-298) - 2004 |
| 5. 16.60 - Derek Libby (5-83) - 2013 |
| 6. 15.54 - Cedric Houston (13-202) - 2009 |
| 7. 15.12 - Brandin Dandridge (8-121) - 2017 |
| 8. 14.64 - Jerris Evans (22-322) - 2001 |
| 9. 14.43 - Jarrett Brooks (21-303) - 2005 |
| 10. 14.30 - Br. Clark (23-329) - 2015 |
|
| Kick return yards |
| 1. 891 - Trey Vaval (26-891) - 2019 |
| 2. 750 - Shamar Griffith (33-750) - 2017 |
| 3. 667 - TJ Fannin (27-667) - 2010 |
| 4. 664 - Brandon Burnside (27-664) - 1998 |
| 5. 616 - Jarrett Brooks (22-616) - 2004 |
| 6. 558 - J. Walker (23-558) - 2013 |
| 7. 542 - Cedric Houston (24-542) - 2008 |
| 8. 537 - Jarrett Brooks (19-537) - 2006 |
| 9. 522 - Jarrett Brooks (19-522) - 2005 |
| 10. 497 - Cedric Houston (24-497) - 2007 |
|
| Kick returns |
| 1. 33 - Shamar Griffith (33-750) - 2017 |
| 2. 27 - TJ Fannin (27-667) - 2010 |
| 27 - Brandon Burnside (27-664) - 1998 |
| 27 - Ferrell McGhee (27-492) - 2008 |
| 5. 26 - Trey Vaval (26-891) - 2019 |
| 26 - Trey Vaval (26-435) - 2021 |
| 7. 24 - Cedric Houston (24-497) - 2007 |
| 24 - Cedric Houston (24-542) - 2008 |
| 9. 23 - J. Walker (23-558) - 2013 |
| 10. 22 - Jarrett Brooks (22-616) - 2004 |
|
| Kick return TDs |
| 1. 2 - Trey Vaval - 2019 |
| 2. 1 - Javerius McGuinn - 2024 |
| 1 - Tarrell Downing - 2011 |
| 1 - Dominic Thomas - 2013 |
| 1 - Jarrett Brooks - 2005 |
| 1 - Cooper Burton - 2019 |
| 1 - Cooper Burton - 2021 |
| 1 - Chad Smith - 1999 |
| 1 - TJ Fannin - 2010 |
| 1 - Jarrett Brooks - 2004 |
|
| Average yards/kick return (min. 10 attempts) |
| 1. 34.27 - Trey Vaval (26-891) - 2019 |
| 2. 31.90 - Darwin Pitts (10-319) - 2002 |
| 3. 30.60 - Tarrell Downing (15-459) - 2010 |
| 4. 28.26 - Jarrett Brooks (19-537) - 2006 |
| 5. 28.00 - Jarrett Brooks (22-616) - 2004 |
| 6. 27.47 - Jarrett Brooks (19-522) - 2005 |
| 7. 26.94 - Ferrell McGhee (18-485) - 2007 |
| 8. 26.27 - TJ Fannin (11-289) - 2012 |
| 9. 25.53 - Dominic Thomas (19-485) - 2013 |
| 10. 24.86 - DiJuan Ussery (14-348) - 2015 |